Prior to reading The Laugh of the
Medusa, I assumed my reaction would be in harmony to the message that Helene
Cixous was trying to exert on the audience. I actually did not read the article
until after we talked about it in class; which was perhaps helpful for
understanding it. The reason for my false assumption is because I tend to agree
with feminist writings and even the so-called radicals in most circumstances. I don’t
think Cixous is a radical feminist really, I just think some of her ideas would
be better suited for a future generation long after ours has made its mark. When Dr.
McD was explaining it in class, what Cixous was trying to say seemed a little bit
odd, but it made sense. And recently, I’ve been learning that things seem most
odd when we don’t understand them fully, so I thought that the meaning of the
article was justified and creative, and if people disliked it or didn’t
understand it, it must have been because they didn’t understand it fully. As
people in the class spoke out about their general dislike of the article (and
particularly the females), I began to feel slightly offended that even the
female audience would not agree with someone who is arguing and campaigning passionately
for a cause with their future freedoms in mind. But now I understand that the
frustration runs deeper than the issue of sexism, it is a frustration that
thrives off of Cixous’ lack of clarity.
I did
not feel as if I were being pushed around and bullied into thinking I must be
more like Cixous while reading the article as some of my classmates had
expressed in class. I tried to keep in mind while reading that this was written
in a time far different than our own, and so the urges to the audience probably
more applicable to the actual era than they are to us now. Women felt isolated;
unable to express themselves in virtually any way which was not under the
authority of a man or influenced by him in some way, although many women still
feel this way now as well. The argument is that we must fight against the
conventional and domestic cages that have been built to hinder women’s true
abilities, and that we must break away from all of these things holding us back
by embracing our most inner and true selves. True liberation will only be
possible once we are in touch with the natural way that our bodies are
imploring us to express ourselves from the true feminine perspective. This must
be broken by refusing to perpetuate the standards and teachings we have been given
since day one; these are men’s rules, and men’s tools for suppressing the population
which has not been given the option of creating their own rules because they
have learned according to the rules constructed by men. One of the most powerfully liberating ways
this is done is through writing, according to Cixous. Through her lens, we
write as we experience most other things. And we experience life hesitantly,
because we are not meant to fully understand the male construction of the
perception and of what things “are” or “should be”. Our language is
uncomfortably construed in order to cater to the species which thrives from the
struggles of women. It keeps women out of the silly cycle of male manipulation
and domination as they seek to rule the world and blah, blah, blah.
These ideas make sense to me when
explained in kindergarten level terms, but only because Cixous has overcomplicated
the writing. I do not understand why she has chosen to write in a manner that
deliberately confuses rather than elaborates. If you are trying to make an
effective point, regardless of whether or not it follows the message you are
attempting to make, you must present it in a way that makes general sense. Her
message fails in this respect. Writing in a non-male form is her statement that
conforming to following tradition equals silence; and I understand that point,
but it makes no sense to me that you would write something with such passion
and a potent message only to have it drown in confusion and disorganization.
Cixous is ahead of the game by
urging women to write as if they are unaffected by the phenomena of androcentrism.
Women writing themselves and their experiences would also be affected by the “phallologocentrism”
of which she speaks, because it can barely be escaped, not even in her case.
Entire courses would have to be taught on women and feminine forms of writing,
girls would have to be segregated from boys in school at the youngest age
possible if this were ever to be accomplished, and the point isn’t even one
that makes itself clear or vital to our progression as a group. There are other
issues at this point in time that pertain to women’s sense of self-importance
and liberation far more clearly. I think that her argument is inapplicable to
the time and for now relatively pointless.
- Mary
This is a poignant critique of Cixous. Though her argument may seem inapplicable now, it certainly transformed a lot of writing and gave women permission to write in ways they had not before. What argument do you think would be relevant today in regards to writing and gender? Or is it just not an issue?
ReplyDeleteGood work.